"What's happening on facebook?" my husband asked.
"Oh you know, the usual, we're all very grateful."
I answered as I scanned the status updates.
Most of them start with the disaster, "A typhoon swept
my home away," or "My dog was run over twice, once in Drive and once
in Reverse," but without exception, they all end the same way, "I'm
so grateful." This is a very Christian thing, which in a link I'm not
certain I understand yet, somehow makes it a very American thing too, this trend towards being verbally grateful, especially when it looks like there isn't much that's great to fill up on.
I had never heard
this before moving to America but I have heard it countless times since I moved
here, most often when a woman or girl falls unexpectedly pregnant. "Oh
well," they smile, "God wouldn't
give me more than I can handle." Are you certain of that? Because I am fairly
sure that there is a homeless man standing in the snow off Colorado Avenue who
could dispute that if he still had his mind. I can't decide if people say these things as a coping mechanism or if they are genuinly worried about undermining God's will. If the latter is so, I hope you'll consider how large the complaints department is and how well equipped God must be to handle these sorts of things.
And why is it so important to be so verbally grateful all the time anyway? Maybe it's just
a matter of getting to the punch line first? Maybe people who say these things
know that if they don't say it, you will? My parents had a robbery where the
car and a lot of things from the living room were stolen while they were asleep
upstairs and all anyone could say when they heard the news was how
"lucky" they were that it wasn't worse. "Funny" she laughed,
"I feel lucky almost all the time but nobody ever mentions it until today which happens to be the one day I haven't been lucky at all."
I'm not saying we
should all mope around and feel sorry for ourselves but maybe there is
something to be said for people who assume gratitude, people who barely ever
discuss it because it's a given that life is precious and we're glad to be here
to experience one more day on this fragile blue marble, even if this particular
day wasn't so hot. Perhaps it's my English heritage, but I find people who cast
an excellent complaint littered perhaps with a few choice curse words and
punctuated with a laugh to be the most human people I wish to know. I feel
somehow related to someone who says, "This morning was so bad that half way
through my staff meeting, I was wishing I had scheduled my mammogram for
today," and I feel I'll never really know someone who says, "My babysitter quit and I'm home with my sick children, but I'm grateful to be here."
And for crying out loud, can we all just stop being facebook
grateful for our husbands? If you're so grateful for your husband, why not
get off the computer and go and give him...you know...hugs. Making a public
statement about it is just flat out lazy and honestly, if you say it more than
once a year, I stop believing you. Maybe these husbands are too busy bringing
their wives coffee or diamond earrings or something, I don't know, but it looks
weird to see all these wives adoring their men who are silent in response.
So here's the point of all this. Try writing updates that
convey how you're doing today without using the words, "blessed" or "grateful."
Why not show us what you see when you look at your life without spelling it out
for us. As your friend and your audience, I want to know you better so don't
keep me at arms length by using all those general words that mask the really
specific thing that's going on. I promise you that no matter how you feel today,
I've been there too and I'd be...well....grateful, for the company.
Cate, you're a fantastic writer. You've given me a lot to think about. I agree with most, but not all. :)
ReplyDeleteFair enough, thanks Kate.
DeleteAnd, what is it with ALL the women in Castle Rock having PERFECT husbands anyway??? ugh!
ReplyDeleteYou didn't get that question on your application to move to Castle Rock? Are you perfectly married and willing to go on and on about it without ever once mentioning how often the love of your life makes you wish you'd been better in a past life?
DeleteThought-provoking. I recently heard of a study that found that profuse and enthusiastic cursing actually reduced pain. The study related to physical pain, but I suspect the same might be true of emotional pain. I wonder if doing the reverse, saying we are blessed and grateful for some calamity, might have the opposite effect, making the pain worse.
ReplyDeleteIt's true. That's how I finished that marathon? If you watch the video of me crossing the finish line, you'll see that I'm clearly saying, "FuckshitdammitBritneySpears."
DeleteI was pondering this driving home from work today. When all the craziness came down in our household, some people suggested that we should be better about praying. Well, whether or not I pray is actually no one's business, but for Pete's sake, if God exists, he/she already knows how deep in the shits it's gotten, and I shouldn't have to ask to have some of it taken away. I like to point out when I'm proud of my kid on FB, but otherwise, I figure I'll do as you say and give my man lots of....hugs... yeah, that's it...hugs.
DeleteI think we as humans tend to take life for granted....maybe thats why we stop and try to remember what we are grateful for, but on that note it is so sad that we don't realize EVERYDAY what we have. there is scripture that says something to the effect "Be grateful in all things and give thanks to God" (or something to that effect.) I am continually thanking God for all that I have, not just our house, job, but our relationships: friends, family (even the crazy ones)
ReplyDeleteI am grateful to have you as a friend and i treasure our coffee talks! You and your family are always in our nightly prayers. We thank God everynight for our friends!
I have taken no offense; i love reading and listening to your views. We are so different in our walks of life that is what makes us so wonderful!